Assertion : HC ≡ C– is more stable than H2C = CH–Reason : HC ≡ C– has more s-character than H2C = CH–
Question
Assertion : HC ≡ C– is more stable than H2C = CH–Reason : HC ≡ C– has more s-character than H2C = CH–
Solution 1
The assertion is correct. The HC≡C– ion is more stable than the H2C=CH– ion. This is due to the fact that the HC≡C– ion has a higher s-character in its hybridization.
Here's the step-by-step explanation:
-
The hybridization of the carbon atoms in HC≡C– is sp, which means it has 50% s-character and 50% p-character.
-
On the other hand, the hybridization of the carbon atoms in H2C=CH– is sp2, which means it has 33.33% s-character and 66.67% p-character.
-
The s-orbital is closer to the nucleus and thus more stable than the p-orbital. Therefore, the more s-character a molecule has, the more stable it is.
-
Therefore, since HC≡C– has more s-character than H2C=CH–, it is more stable.
So, the reason is correct and it is the correct explanation of the assertion.
Solution 2
The assertion and reason are both correct and they are related.
Step 1: Understanding the structures HC ≡ C– is an alkyne with a triple bond between the two carbon atoms. H2C = CH– is an alkene with a double bond between the two carbon atoms.
Step 2: Understanding s-character In hybridization, s-character refers to the percentage of an orbital's character that is derived from the s orbital. The more s-character an orbital has, the closer the electrons are to the nucleus, and the lower the energy and more stable the molecule.
Step 3: Applying s-character to the structures In HC ≡ C–, the carbon atoms are sp hybridized, meaning they have 50% s-character. In H2C = CH–, the carbon atoms are sp2 hybridized, meaning they have 33% s-character.
Step 4: Conclusion Since HC ≡ C– has more s-character than H2C = CH–, it is more stable. Therefore, the assertion is correct, and the reason correctly explains why.
Similar Questions
The oxidation numbers of C in HCN and HNC,respectively, a
Out of (CH3)3C–Br and (CH3)3C–I, which one is more reactive towards SN1and why
Multiplicity of C-C bond decreases with increase in s-character
Under ordinary condition hydrogen atom is more stable than hydrogen molecule.Question 3Answera.Falseb.True
Which of following has maximum affinity for protonation ?A CH3–C≡N B CH2=CH–NH2 C CH3NH2 D H3C–NH–CH3
Upgrade your grade with Knowee
Get personalized homework help. Review tough concepts in more detail, or go deeper into your topic by exploring other relevant questions.