Provide an argument using this argument form. The premises must ALL be false, and the conclusion true. Mention "cats' in your argument.Either A or B is true. If C is true then D is. If C is false, so is B. But if D is talse, A is too. So D must be true.
Question
Provide an argument using this argument form. The premises must ALL be false, and the conclusion true. Mention "cats' in your argument.Either A or B is true. If C is true then D is. If C is false, so is B. But if D is talse, A is too. So D must be true.
Solution
Here's an argument that fits the form you've provided, with all false premises and a true conclusion:
Premise 1: Either cats can fly or dogs can speak human languages. Premise 2: If cats can breathe underwater, then dogs can speak human languages. Premise 3: If cats cannot breathe underwater, then dogs cannot speak human languages. Premise 4: But if dogs cannot speak human languages, then cats can fly. Conclusion: Therefore, dogs can speak human languages.
In this argument, all the premises are false. Cats cannot fly, dogs cannot speak human languages, and cats cannot breathe underwater. However, the conclusion is true because it's a false statement (dogs can speak human languages) derived from false premises.
Similar Questions
Provide an argument using this argument form. The premises must All be false, and the conclusion true. Either A or B is true. If C is true then D is. If C is false, so is B. But If D is false, A is too. So D must be true. Mention All cats are human' in the argument.
Statements:Some dogs are cats.All animals are cats.All cats are whites.Conclusions:I. All those dogs which are cats are also whites.II. All the animals may or may not be dogsOptionsIf only conclusion I followsIf either conclusion I or conclusion II followsIf both conclusion I and conclusion II followIf neither conclusion I nor conclusion II followsIf only conclusion II follows
Directions: In the following question, only one Conclusion is given and five statements are given as a), b), c), d) and e. From this, you have to take the statements to be true even if they seem to be at variance with commonly known facts and then decide which of the given statement logically follows.Conclusions: All those dogs that are cats are also whitesAll the animals may be dog.Some whites are animalSome cats are animalsa) Statements : No dogs are cats. All animals are cats. No cats arewhitesb) Statements : All dogs are cats. No animals are cats. All cats arewhitesc) Statements : All dogs are cats. All animals are cats. All cats are whitesd) Statements : Some dogs are cats. Some animals are cats. All cats are whitese) Statements : All dogs are cats. Some animals are cats. Some cats are whites
Given two statements, verify the conclusions and mark the answerStatements: Some Cats are Rats. Some Rats are Ants.Conclusions:I. No Rat is Ant. II. No Cat is Ant.
Directions: In the following question, only Conclusion is given and statements. From this you have to take the statements to be true even if they seem to be at variance with commonly known facts and then decide which of the given statement logically follows. Conclusions: I.Some rats are dog is a possibility II.Some hamsters are cats III.Some hamsters are rats IV.All dogs are rats is a possibilityChoices:- Statements I: Some dogs are cats. Some cats are rats. Some rats are hamsters. Statements II: All dogs are cats. Some cats are not rats. Some rats are hamsters Statements III: No dogs are cats. All rats are cats. All rats are hamsters Statements IV: All dogs are cats. Some cats are rats. All rats are hamsters
Upgrade your grade with Knowee
Get personalized homework help. Review tough concepts in more detail, or go deeper into your topic by exploring other relevant questions.