James leaves his car with Good Service Garage for repairs, but fails to pay. Charles claims the car from Good Service Garage. He is able to prove that he is the true owner of the car, which was stolen from him by James. Which ONE of the following statements is CORRECT?a.Good Service Garage has a debtor and creditor lien against James.b.Good Service Garage has a debtor and creditor lien against Charles.c.Good Service Garage has an enrichment lien against Charles in respect of any work done to the car, either useful or unnecessary.d.Good Service Garage has a debtor and creditor lien against Charles in respect of luxurious expenses on the car.
Question
James leaves his car with Good Service Garage for repairs, but fails to pay. Charles claims the car from Good Service Garage. He is able to prove that he is the true owner of the car, which was stolen from him by James. Which ONE of the following statements is CORRECT?a.Good Service Garage has a debtor and creditor lien against James.b.Good Service Garage has a debtor and creditor lien against Charles.c.Good Service Garage has an enrichment lien against Charles in respect of any work done to the car, either useful or unnecessary.d.Good Service Garage has a debtor and creditor lien against Charles in respect of luxurious expenses on the car.
Solution
Let's analyze the situation step by step:
-
James leaves his car with Good Service Garage for repairs, but fails to pay.
- This indicates that James owes money to Good Service Garage for the repair services provided.
-
Charles claims the car from Good Service Garage.
- Charles is asserting his right to the car.
-
He is able to prove that he is the true owner of the car, which was stolen from him by James.
- This establishes that Charles is the legitimate owner of the car, and James had no rightful ownership.
Now, let's evaluate each statement:
a. Good Service Garage has a debtor and creditor lien against James.
- This is correct because James owes money to Good Service Garage for the repairs. A debtor and creditor lien is applicable here as James is the debtor.
b. Good Service Garage has a debtor and creditor lien against Charles.
- This is incorrect because Charles is not the debtor; he is the rightful owner of the car.
c. Good Service Garage has an enrichment lien against Charles in respect of any work done to the car, either useful or unnecessary.
- This is incorrect because an enrichment lien would apply if Charles had requested the services or benefited from them. Since the car was stolen from him, he did not engage Good Service Garage for the repairs.
d. Good Service Garage has a debtor and creditor lien against Charles in respect of luxurious expenses on the car.
- This is incorrect because Charles is not the debtor, and luxurious expenses do not change the nature of the lien.
Therefore, the correct statement is:
a. Good Service Garage has a debtor and creditor lien against James.
Similar Questions
Consider the following statements below: Statement 1: The creditor may bring the appropriate actions to protect and preserve his right only after the fulfillment of the condition. Statement 2: The debtor may recover what he has paid if he believed by mistake that the condition has been fulfilled.1 pointOnly statement 2 is true.Only statement 1 is true.Both statements are false.Both statements are true.
Which ONE of the following statements is INCORRECT?a.In a contract of suretyship, a surety renders him - or herself liable towards a creditor for the proper compliance with the obligations of a debtor.b.The surety may not render himself liable for an amount less than the principal debt.c.In a contract of suretyship, there are two debtors, namely the debtor in the principal agreement and the debtor in the contract of suretyship.d.A contract of suretyship is accessory to the principal obligation between the principal debtor and creditor.
Multiple Choice QuestionWhen Jim obtains the needed computer maintenance services from a supplier who agrees to receive payment for those services within two months, Jim is obtaining ______.Multiple choice question.bartering servicesa line of creditdebt financingtrade credit
In bankruptcy cases, the claims of lawyers are Blank______ the claims of senior bondholders.Multiple choice question.considered equal toonly paid aftergiven priority over
In bankruptcy cases, the claims of lawyers are Blank______ the claims of senior bondholders.Multiple choice question.given priority overonly paid afterconsidered equal to
Upgrade your grade with Knowee
Get personalized homework help. Review tough concepts in more detail, or go deeper into your topic by exploring other relevant questions.