Suggest why taking stem cells from an umbilical cord is more ethically acceptable than using stem cells from a donated embryo.Umbilical cord stem cells are an exact match to that baby, so the stem cells can be stored in case they are needed for medical treatments in the future.Umbilical cord stem cells are easier and cheaper to collect than embryonic stem cells.The embryo could potentially be a human life and cannot give consent to be used in this way.I DON'T KNOWSUBMIT ANSWER
Question
Suggest why taking stem cells from an umbilical cord is more ethically acceptable than using stem cells from a donated embryo.Umbilical cord stem cells are an exact match to that baby, so the stem cells can be stored in case they are needed for medical treatments in the future.Umbilical cord stem cells are easier and cheaper to collect than embryonic stem cells.The embryo could potentially be a human life and cannot give consent to be used in this way.I DON'T KNOWSUBMIT ANSWER
Solution
The ethical acceptability of using stem cells from an umbilical cord rather than a donated embryo can be attributed to several reasons:
-
Consent: The umbilical cord is typically discarded after birth, and the extraction of stem cells does not harm the mother or the baby. Therefore, it is easier to obtain informed consent for this procedure. On the other hand, an embryo has the potential to develop into a full human being, and it cannot give consent for its use in research or treatment.
-
Potential for life: An embryo has the potential to develop into a full human being, so using it for stem cell research or treatment raises ethical issues about the sanctity of life. In contrast, stem cells from the umbilical cord do not have this potential, so their use is less ethically contentious.
-
Match for the baby: The stem cells from an umbilical cord are an exact match for the baby from whom they were taken. This means they can be stored and used for future medical treatments for that individual, reducing the risk of rejection that can occur with stem cells from other sources.
-
Cost and ease of collection: Collecting stem cells from the umbilical cord is a relatively simple and inexpensive procedure, compared to the process of obtaining embryonic stem cells. This makes it a more feasible option for many people.
In conclusion, while both sources of stem cells have their advantages and potential uses, the use of umbilical cord stem cells is generally considered more ethically acceptable due to the reasons outlined above.
Similar Questions
Which of the following is an advantage of using embryonic stem cells rather than bone marrow stem cells?Use of bone marrow stem cells has been done many many times and is considered safe, whereas embryonic stem cells still need more research.Embryonic stem cells divide more quickly than bone marrow stem cells.Consent is given by the donor for bone marrow stem cell collection, whereas the use of embryonic stem cells has ethical issues.
ethical reasons against embryonic stem cell research
Both embryonic stem cell (ESC) research and induced pluripotent stem cell research (iPSC) hold promise for medical treatments. However, some religious groups raise ethical concerns about embryonic stem cells. Why might induced pluripotent stem cells be viewed as a more acceptable alternative by these groups?Read Less(a) iPSC research involves adult cells, whereas ESCs are harvested from embryos.(b) iPSC research requires fewer legal restrictions compared to ESC.(c) iPSC research produces more stem cells than ESC research.(d) iPSC research is a more recent discovery, and religious views have not caught up yet.
Are induced pluripotent stem (iPS) cells really the ‘ethical’ alternative to embryonic stem (ES) cells? Provide a rationale for your answer.
Stem cells can also be obtained from human embryos. Evaluate the use of stem cells from a patient’s own bone marrow instead of stem cells from an embryo. Give a conclusion to your answer. ___________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________
Upgrade your grade with Knowee
Get personalized homework help. Review tough concepts in more detail, or go deeper into your topic by exploring other relevant questions.