Select the correct answer.Aiden is writing a literary argument about William Golding’s Lord of the Flies. His essay argues that the character Ralph symbolizes leadership. Which sentence best expresses a counterclaim? A. For example, Ralph tries to convince the other characters to follow rules. B. Furthermore, Ralph struggles to understand why the boys on the island do not want to follow rules. C. As a result, the boys on the island elect Ralph as their leader. D. Nevertheless, it may be argued that Jack possesses greater leadership qualities.
Question
Select the correct answer.Aiden is writing a literary argument about William Golding’s Lord of the Flies. His essay argues that the character Ralph symbolizes leadership. Which sentence best expresses a counterclaim? A. For example, Ralph tries to convince the other characters to follow rules. B. Furthermore, Ralph struggles to understand why the boys on the island do not want to follow rules. C. As a result, the boys on the island elect Ralph as their leader. D. Nevertheless, it may be argued that Jack possesses greater leadership qualities.
Solution
To determine which sentence best expresses a counterclaim in Aiden's literary argument, we need to identify a statement that challenges or opposes the main argument that Ralph symbolizes leadership. Let's analyze each option:
A. "For example, Ralph tries to convince the other characters to follow rules."
- This sentence supports the main argument by providing evidence of Ralph's leadership.
B. "Furthermore, Ralph struggles to understand why the boys on the island do not want to follow rules."
- This sentence also supports the main argument by highlighting Ralph's efforts and challenges as a leader.
C. "As a result, the boys on the island elect Ralph as their leader."
- This sentence reinforces the main argument by showing that Ralph is recognized as a leader by the other boys.
D. "Nevertheless, it may be argued that Jack possesses greater leadership qualities."
- This sentence introduces a counterclaim by suggesting that another character, Jack, might have stronger leadership qualities than Ralph.
Therefore, the sentence that best expresses a counterclaim is:
D. Nevertheless, it may be argued that Jack possesses greater leadership qualities.
Similar Questions
Youwrite a conclusion for the essay: How far does Golding present Ralph as a strong character in Lord of the Flies?
Set during a global war, Lord of the Flies offers a view of what society might look like trying to rebuild after a large scale man made catastrophe. In their attempt to rebuild society, the boys cannot agree on a new order and eventually fall into savagery. Ralph comes to realize that social order, fairness and thoughtfulness have little value in a world where basic survival a struggle, such as after a devastating war. The paratrooper who lands on the island reminds the reader that while the boys are struggling to survive peacefully on the island, the world at large is still at war. Even in their isolation and youth, the boys are unable to avoid violence. In their descent into torture and murder, they mirror the warring world around them.
Pretend you’re writing an essay on the character of Piggy. Which piece of evidence fits the best in the blank?Piggy's intelligence gives him an insight into Jack's character. For example, he says __________. He sees what Jack is capable of and foreshadows his own fate."hates you too, Ralph...You got him over the fire; an’ you’re chief an’ he isn’t…""He can’t hurt you: but if you stand out of the way he’d hurt the next thing. And that’s me.""I thought they wanted the conch."
. What makes Lord of the Flies an Allegory?*
Does the author present a compelling argument?
Upgrade your grade with Knowee
Get personalized homework help. Review tough concepts in more detail, or go deeper into your topic by exploring other relevant questions.