A researcher at a Canadian institution eligible to receive Agency funding wishes to determine the frequency of cannabis consumption among high school students in Canada. The researcher will create a website that includes a secure link to a survey for students wishing to participate in the research. For scientific reasons, only students who have already used cannabis will be invited to participate and respond anonymously to the survey (please answer all questions by YES or NO).The researcher wishes to compare the frequency of cannabis consumption depending on the sex and gender of the students. Is such an analysis ethically acceptable?
Question
A researcher at a Canadian institution eligible to receive Agency funding wishes to determine the frequency of cannabis consumption among high school students in Canada. The researcher will create a website that includes a secure link to a survey for students wishing to participate in the research. For scientific reasons, only students who have already used cannabis will be invited to participate and respond anonymously to the survey (please answer all questions by YES or NO).The researcher wishes to compare the frequency of cannabis consumption depending on the sex and gender of the students. Is such an analysis ethically acceptable?
Solution
The ethical acceptability of conducting an analysis comparing the frequency of cannabis consumption based on the sex and gender of high school students in Canada depends on several factors.
-
Informed Consent: The researcher must ensure that all participants provide informed consent before participating in the survey. This includes clearly explaining the purpose of the study, the potential risks and benefits, and the voluntary nature of participation. Participants should also be informed about the anonymity and confidentiality measures in place to protect their privacy.
-
Privacy and Confidentiality: The researcher must take appropriate measures to protect the privacy and confidentiality of the participants. This includes using a secure website and ensuring that the survey responses cannot be linked back to individual participants. The researcher should also clearly communicate how the data will be stored, analyzed, and reported in a way that protects the participants' identities.
-
Potential Harm: The researcher should carefully consider the potential harm that may arise from conducting this analysis. In this case, since the survey is only targeting students who have already used cannabis, there is a risk of stigmatizing or singling out these students. The researcher should take steps to minimize any potential harm and ensure that the study does not contribute to further marginalization or discrimination.
-
Scientific Validity: The researcher should ensure that the analysis comparing the frequency of cannabis consumption based on sex and gender is scientifically valid and relevant. This includes using appropriate statistical methods and ensuring that the sample size is sufficient to draw meaningful conclusions. The researcher should also consider other relevant factors that may influence cannabis consumption, such as age, socioeconomic status, and geographic location.
Overall, conducting an analysis comparing the frequency of cannabis consumption based on the sex and gender of high school students can be ethically acceptable if the researcher takes appropriate measures to protect the participants' privacy and confidentiality, obtains informed consent, minimizes potential harm, and ensures scientific validity. It is important for the researcher to consult with an ethics review board or committee to ensure that the study meets ethical standards and guidelines.
Similar Questions
A researcher at a Canadian institution eligible to receive Agency funding wishes to determine the frequency of cannabis consumption among high school students in Canada. The researcher will create a website that includes a secure link to a survey for students wishing to participate in the research. For scientific reasons, only students who have already used cannabis will be invited to participate and respond anonymously to the survey (please answer all questions by YES or NO).The researcher believes that some of the high school students who will respond to the survey may come from an Indigenous community. However, the researcher does not intend to make Indigeneity an element of their analysis of the findings. Moreover, it will not be possible for the researcher to know which participants are from Indigenous communities, because the survey does not include socio-demographic questions that would allow such description. In this case, is the researcher required to do community engagement?
A researcher at a Canadian institution eligible to receive Agency funding wishes to determine the frequency of cannabis consumption among high school students in Canada. The researcher will create a website that includes a secure link to a survey for students wishing to participate in the research. For scientific reasons, only students who have already used cannabis will be invited to participate and respond anonymously to the survey (please answer all questions by YES or NO).The researcher proposes to ask participants to provide minimal information about themselves, such as sex, gender, age, and postal code (indirect identifiers). However, the participants will not be required to provide direct identifiers such as their name and the researcher will not collect their IP address. Considering the information that will be collected, can the data be considered anonymous?
A researcher at a Canadian institution eligible to receive Agency funding wishes to determine the frequency of cannabis consumption among high school students in Canada. The researcher will create a website that includes a secure link to a survey for students wishing to participate in the research. For scientific reasons, only students who have already used cannabis will be invited to participate and respond anonymously to the survey (please answer all questions by YES or NO).The researcher proposes to ask teachers to inform their students that the study exists, and to tell them where they can access the link to the survey, in case they wish to complete it, at home or anywhere outside the classroom. The schoolboard has approved the proposal, the teachers are not members of the research team and the context is not likely to exercise coercive pressure on students to participate in the study. Is the proposal ethically acceptable?
A researcher at a Canadian institution eligible to receive Agency funding wishes to determine the frequency of cannabis consumption among high school students in Canada. The researcher will create a website that includes a secure link to a survey for students wishing to participate in the research. For scientific reasons, only students who have already used cannabis will be invited to participate and respond anonymously to the survey (please answer all questions by YES or NO).If the REB determines that the targeted population and prospective participants have the capacity to decide for themselves to participate in this study, must the REB also require that the researcher seek the authorization of a parent or authorized third party prior to the participation of minors in this context? No Yes
The researcher proposes to ask teachers to inform their students that the study exists, and to tell them where they can access the link to the survey, in case they wish to complete it, at home or anywhere outside the classroom. The schoolboard has approved the proposal, the teachers are not members of the research team and the context is not likely to exercise coercive pressure on students to participate in the study. Is the proposal ethically acceptable?
Upgrade your grade with Knowee
Get personalized homework help. Review tough concepts in more detail, or go deeper into your topic by exploring other relevant questions.