Four candidates, Harrison (H), Lennon (L), McCartney (M), and Starr (S), are running for regional manager. After the polls close, ranked ballots are tallied, and the results are summarized in the table.Number of Ballots Cast27 97 47 83 32 16 241st choice H L L M M S S2nd choice L M S L L H M3rd choice S H M H S L H4th choice M S H S H M L(a) How many votes were cast? votes(b) Use the plurality method of voting to determine the winner.HarrisonLennon McCartneyStarr(c) What percent of the votes did the winner in part (b) receive? (Round your answer to the nearest whole number.) %(d) Use the instant runoff method to determine the winner.HarrisonLennon McCartneyStarr(e) What percent of the votes did the winner in part (d) receive? (Round your answer to the nearest whole number.) %(f) Use the Borda count method to determine the winner.HarrisonLennon McCartneyStarr(g) How many points did the winner in part (f) receive? points(h) Use the pairwise comparison method to determine the winner.HarrisonLennon McCartneyStarr(i) How many points did the winner in part (h) receive? points
Question
Four candidates, Harrison (H), Lennon (L), McCartney (M), and Starr (S), are running for regional manager. After the polls close, ranked ballots are tallied, and the results are summarized in the table.Number of Ballots Cast27 97 47 83 32 16 241st choice H L L M M S S2nd choice L M S L L H M3rd choice S H M H S L H4th choice M S H S H M L(a) How many votes were cast? votes(b) Use the plurality method of voting to determine the winner.HarrisonLennon McCartneyStarr(c) What percent of the votes did the winner in part (b) receive? (Round your answer to the nearest whole number.) %(d) Use the instant runoff method to determine the winner.HarrisonLennon McCartneyStarr(e) What percent of the votes did the winner in part (d) receive? (Round your answer to the nearest whole number.) %(f) Use the Borda count method to determine the winner.HarrisonLennon McCartneyStarr(g) How many points did the winner in part (f) receive? points(h) Use the pairwise comparison method to determine the winner.HarrisonLennon McCartneyStarr(i) How many points did the winner in part (h) receive? points
Solution
(a) To find the total number of votes cast, sum the number of ballots in each column:
27 + 97 + 47 + 83 + 32 + 16 + 24 = 326 votes
(b) Using the plurality method, we count only the first-choice votes for each candidate:
- Harrison (H): 27
- Lennon (L): 97 + 47 = 144
- McCartney (M): 83 + 32 = 115
- Starr (S): 16 + 24 = 40
The candidate with the most first-choice votes is Lennon (L) with 144 votes.
(c) To find the percentage of votes the winner received:
(144 / 326) * 100 ≈ 44%
(d) Using the instant runoff method, we eliminate the candidate with the fewest first-choice votes and redistribute those votes according to the next preferences until one candidate has a majority.
First round:
- Harrison (H): 27
- Lennon (L): 144
- McCartney (M): 115
- Starr (S): 40
Starr (S) is eliminated. Redistribute Starr's votes:
- 16 votes go to Harrison (H)
- 24 votes go to McCartney (M)
Second round:
- Harrison (H): 27 + 16 = 43
- Lennon (L): 144
- McCartney (M): 115 + 24 = 139
Harrison (H) is eliminated. Redistribute Harrison's votes:
- 27 votes go to Lennon (L)
- 16 votes go to McCartney (M)
Final round:
- Lennon (L): 144 + 27 = 171
- McCartney (M): 139 + 16 = 155
Lennon (L) wins with 171 votes.
(e) To find the percentage of votes the winner received in the instant runoff:
(171 / 326) * 100 ≈ 52%
(f) Using the Borda count method, assign points based on ranking positions (4 points for 1st choice, 3 points for 2nd choice, 2 points for 3rd choice, 1 point for 4th choice):
- Harrison (H): (27 * 4) + (97 * 3) + (47 * 2) + (83 * 1) = 108 + 291 + 94 + 83 = 576
- Lennon (L): (97 * 4) + (47 * 4) + (83 * 3) + (32 * 2) + (16 * 1) = 388 + 188 + 249 + 64 + 16 = 905
- McCartney (M): (83 * 4) + (32 * 4) + (16 * 3) + (24 * 2) + (27 * 1) = 332 + 128 + 48 + 48 + 27 = 583
- Starr (S): (16 * 4) + (24 * 4) + (27 * 3) + (97 * 2) + (47 * 1) = 64 + 96 + 81 + 194 + 47 = 482
The candidate with the most points is Lennon (L) with 905 points.
(g) The winner in part (f) received 905 points.
(h) Using the pairwise comparison method, compare each candidate against each other:
- Harrison vs. Lennon: Lennon wins
- Harrison vs. McCartney: McCartney wins
- Harrison vs. Starr: Harrison wins
- Lennon vs. McCartney: Lennon wins
- Lennon vs. Starr: Lennon wins
- McCartney vs. Starr: McCartney wins
Points:
- Harrison: 1
- Lennon: 3
- McCartney: 2
- Starr: 0
The candidate with the most points is Lennon (L) with 3 points.
(i) The winner in part (h) received 3 points.
Similar Questions
The student government is holding elections for president. There are 4 candidates (labeled A, B, C, and D for convenience). The preference for the election is as follows:Candidates Ranking Ranking Ranking Ranking Ranking RankingA 4 3 2 1 1 3B 3 1 3 3 4 2C 1 2 4 2 3 4D 2 4 1 4 2 1# of votes 120 50 40 90 60 100Questions:How many voters voted in this election?How many voters are needed for a majority? For a plurality?
Consider the given preference schedule with the number of voters ranking the candidates in a local community plebiscite.Rank13155121stWXYY2ndXWZX3rdZZXW4thYYWZ21. Determine the winner by Majority Rule.Group of answer choicesNo winnerCandidate YCandidate XCandidate W
The managers of Prints Alive (a local silk-screening business) are planning a party for their 30 employees. There are three possible locations for the party: the warehouse (W), the park (P), or the beach (B). The employees are asked to rank these choices in order of preference, and the results are summarized in the table.Number of Ballots Cast6 7 12 51st choice P P B W2nd choice B W W B3rd choice W B P P(a) How many votes were cast? votes(b) Use the plurality method of voting to determine the winner.the beachthe park the warehouse(c) What percent of the votes did the winner in part (b) receive? (Round your answer to the nearest whole number.) %
Consider the given preference schedule with the number of voters ranking the candidates in a local community plebiscite.Rank13155121stWXYY2ndXWZX3rdZZXW4thYYWZ22. Compute candidate W's Borda score.Group of answer choices9614512683
Winners in primary elections in Texas are determined by plurality vote. Group of answer choicesTrueFalse
Upgrade your grade with Knowee
Get personalized homework help. Review tough concepts in more detail, or go deeper into your topic by exploring other relevant questions.