Review the claim and the two pieces of evidence.Independent of their meanings, some words have a more pleasing sound than others.Evidence A: A linguist analyzed lists of words that sound the most beautiful to English speakers. He noted sound-related trends among the "beautiful" words, such as having three syllables, having the accent on the first syllable, and containing the sounds m and l.Evidence B: The British Council surveyed over forty thousand people worldwide about what the most beautiful word in the English language is. Words with positive meanings dominated the list: mother, passion, smile, love, and eternity were the top five choices.Why is Evidence A stronger than Evidence B?Evidence B is anecdotal. It is based on the opinions of a few people who aren't experts.Evidence B does not directly support the claim. It does not talk about how words sound independent of their meanings.Submit
Question
Review the claim and the two pieces of evidence.Independent of their meanings, some words have a more pleasing sound than others.Evidence A: A linguist analyzed lists of words that sound the most beautiful to English speakers. He noted sound-related trends among the "beautiful" words, such as having three syllables, having the accent on the first syllable, and containing the sounds m and l.Evidence B: The British Council surveyed over forty thousand people worldwide about what the most beautiful word in the English language is. Words with positive meanings dominated the list: mother, passion, smile, love, and eternity were the top five choices.Why is Evidence A stronger than Evidence B?Evidence B is anecdotal. It is based on the opinions of a few people who aren't experts.Evidence B does not directly support the claim. It does not talk about how words sound independent of their meanings.Submit
Solution
The question asks why Evidence A is stronger than Evidence B.
Step 1: Understand the claim The claim is that some words sound more pleasing than others, regardless of their meanings.
Step 2: Analyze Evidence A Evidence A is a study conducted by a linguist who analyzed lists of words that sound the most beautiful to English speakers. He noted sound-related trends among the "beautiful" words, such as having three syllables, having the accent on the first syllable, and containing the sounds m and l. This evidence directly supports the claim as it focuses on the sound of the words, not their meanings.
Step 3: Analyze Evidence B Evidence B is a survey conducted by the British Council that asked over forty thousand people worldwide about what the most beautiful word in the English language is. The top five choices were words with positive meanings: mother, passion, smile, love, and eternity. This evidence does not directly support the claim as it focuses on the meanings of the words, not their sounds.
Step 4: Compare the two pieces of evidence While both pieces of evidence are valuable, Evidence A is stronger in supporting the claim because it directly addresses the sound of words, which is the focus of the claim. On the other hand, Evidence B focuses on the meanings of words, which is not relevant to the claim.
Step 5: Conclusion Therefore, Evidence A is stronger than Evidence B because it directly supports the claim by focusing on the sound of words, while Evidence B does not.
Similar Questions
Which is a reason that writers often have favorite words?A.Words are more interesting if they have unusual origins and meanings.B.Words' sounds and meanings appeal to people in different ways.C.Certain words are objectively superior to others because of their sound.D.The best words are ones all readers know and understand immediately.
What would be a good example of what Kant regards as beautiful?Group of answer choicesa beautiful human facethe concept of the goodabstract designsa cathedral
Choose the poem that uses assonance.London, my beautiful,It is not the sunsetNor the pale green skyShimmering through the curtainFrom fairest creatures we desire increase,That thereby beauty's rose might never die,But as the riper should by time decease,His tender heir might bear his memory.
Choose the option that is closest to the contextual meaning of the following word and phrase: Height of eleganceQuestion 33Select one:a.Tastefulnessb.Highly opulentc.Arroganced.Highly satisfying
Which of the following is not true of “Amazing Grace?”Multiple ChoiceThe words were written by a former captain of a slave ship.It is based on a pentatonic scale.It is written in the style of European art song.It can be performed during times of both joy and grief.
Upgrade your grade with Knowee
Get personalized homework help. Review tough concepts in more detail, or go deeper into your topic by exploring other relevant questions.