The Fallacy fallacy is an unacceptable premise because:Group of answer choicesTwo wrongs don't make a rightYour opponent making a mistake doesn't prevent you from making oneThey could be right even if they have bad reasonsTheir argument could be cogent even with a minor fallacy
Question
The Fallacy fallacy is an unacceptable premise because:Group of answer choicesTwo wrongs don't make a rightYour opponent making a mistake doesn't prevent you from making oneThey could be right even if they have bad reasonsTheir argument could be cogent even with a minor fallacy
Solution
The Fallacy fallacy is an unacceptable premise because:
-
Two wrongs don't make a right: Just because someone else has made a logical fallacy in their argument, it doesn't mean that your argument is automatically correct. Both arguments could be flawed.
-
Your opponent making a mistake doesn't prevent you from making one: Even if your opponent has made a logical fallacy, it doesn't mean that you are immune from making logical fallacies in your own argument.
-
They could be right even if they have bad reasons: Sometimes, a person can arrive at the correct conclusion, even if the reasoning they used to get there was flawed. This is why it's important to evaluate the conclusion of an argument on its own merits, not just based on the quality of the reasoning that led to it.
-
Their argument could be cogent even with a minor fallacy: A minor logical fallacy in an argument doesn't necessarily invalidate the entire argument. It's possible for an argument to still be cogent (i.e., clear, logical, and convincing) even if it contains a minor fallacy.
Similar Questions
Argumentum non sequitur: This fallacy occurs when the conclusion doesn’t necessarily follow from the premise.Group of answer choicesTrueFalse
This type of fallacy relies upon the use of an argument or an idea that is perceived to be popular among the masses, and so, it must be the truth:Question 9Select one:a.Ad hominemb.Non-Sequiturc.Non-starterd.Ad populum
Fallacy of Defective / Weak Induction is a fallacy in which the premises are too weak or ineffective to warrant the conclusion.Group of answer choicesTrueFalseNext
Hasty Generalization (Converse Accident) is the fallacy occurs when there is a reasonable likelihood that the sample is not representative of the group. Such a likelihood may arise if the sample is either too small or not randomly selected.Group of answer choicesTrueFalse
The statement “My opponent wants your children to be exposed to ideas that will make them hate our nation.” is a fallacy calledGroup of answer choicesappealing to traditioncreating a straw manbegging the questioncreating a red herring
Upgrade your grade with Knowee
Get personalized homework help. Review tough concepts in more detail, or go deeper into your topic by exploring other relevant questions.