Theory of mind (ToM) refers to the ability of an individual to make inferencesabout what others may be thinking or feeling and to predict what they may doin a given situation based on those inferences. Discussions of ToM focus almostexclusively on inferred cognitive structures and processes and shed little lighton the actual behaviors involved. In this article, I (a) selectively overview theliterature on ToM, (b) suggest that the behavioral relations referred to by ToMscholars can be described and explained parsimoniously within the theoreticalframework of behavior analysis, (c) argue that the verbal behaviors that definemost ToM tasks are acquired as a function of the language environment of theyoung child, and (d) point out that B. F. Skinner (1945) proposed what amountsto a ToM more than 60 years ago.In the last chapter of The Selfish Gene, Richard Dawkins (1976) introducedthe term meme to refer to a unit of cultural replication analogous to thebiological unit of replication—the gene. Examples of memes include tunes,ideas, and catchphrases. According to Dawkins, “Just as genes propagatethemselves in the gene pool by leaping from body to body via sperm or eggs,so memes propagate themselves in the meme pool by leaping from brain tobrain via a process, which in the broad sense can be called imitation” (p. 206).Although some may quarrel with Dawkins’ understanding of imitation, theterm meme has attained a certain level of descriptive currency.1I mention memes because an excellent example of a meme is theconstruct of “theory of mind.” Salzinger (2006) recently wrote, “‘Times theyare a-changin’,’ as Bob Dylan succinctly put it. . . . When you enter theory ofmind in PsycINFO, it returns 2,176 entries—books, book chapters, and journalarticles. Not only that, its frequency of use is such that it has been awardedan acronym, namely, ToM.” Since the term theory of mind was first used by1 Describing ToM as a meme implies that it confers some favorable advantage on those whotalk about it. Understanding the favorable advantage, however, means understanding the socialand professional contingencies responsible for individuals using the term and studying whateverbehaviors are said to reflect it. Thus, an ontogenetic-selection analogy based on establishedprinciples of learning better explains the popularity of a term than a phylogenetic-selectionanalogy does.The author is grateful to Matthew P. Normand and Julie A. Riggott, but especially to Edward K.Morris, for their helpful comments on earlier drafts of this article.Correspondence concerning this article should be addressed to [email protected].
Question
Theory of mind (ToM) refers to the ability of an individual to make inferencesabout what others may be thinking or feeling and to predict what they may doin a given situation based on those inferences. Discussions of ToM focus almostexclusively on inferred cognitive structures and processes and shed little lighton the actual behaviors involved. In this article, I (a) selectively overview theliterature on ToM, (b) suggest that the behavioral relations referred to by ToMscholars can be described and explained parsimoniously within the theoreticalframework of behavior analysis, (c) argue that the verbal behaviors that definemost ToM tasks are acquired as a function of the language environment of theyoung child, and (d) point out that B. F. Skinner (1945) proposed what amountsto a ToM more than 60 years ago.In the last chapter of The Selfish Gene, Richard Dawkins (1976) introducedthe term meme to refer to a unit of cultural replication analogous to thebiological unit of replication—the gene. Examples of memes include tunes,ideas, and catchphrases. According to Dawkins, “Just as genes propagatethemselves in the gene pool by leaping from body to body via sperm or eggs,so memes propagate themselves in the meme pool by leaping from brain tobrain via a process, which in the broad sense can be called imitation” (p. 206).Although some may quarrel with Dawkins’ understanding of imitation, theterm meme has attained a certain level of descriptive currency.1I mention memes because an excellent example of a meme is theconstruct of “theory of mind.” Salzinger (2006) recently wrote, “‘Times theyare a-changin’,’ as Bob Dylan succinctly put it. . . . When you enter theory ofmind in PsycINFO, it returns 2,176 entries—books, book chapters, and journalarticles. Not only that, its frequency of use is such that it has been awardedan acronym, namely, ToM.” Since the term theory of mind was first used by1 Describing ToM as a meme implies that it confers some favorable advantage on those whotalk about it. Understanding the favorable advantage, however, means understanding the socialand professional contingencies responsible for individuals using the term and studying whateverbehaviors are said to reflect it. Thus, an ontogenetic-selection analogy based on establishedprinciples of learning better explains the popularity of a term than a phylogenetic-selectionanalogy does.The author is grateful to Matthew P. Normand and Julie A. Riggott, but especially to Edward K.Morris, for their helpful comments on earlier drafts of this article.Correspondence concerning this article should be addressed to [email protected].
Solution
I'm sorry, but you didn't provide a text for me to respond to. Could you please provide the text?
Similar Questions
According to behaviourism, what is the primary method for studying the mind?1 pointIntrospectionPhilosophical analysisDirect observation of behaviourNeuroimaging studies
The study of inner thoughts and feelings is to the study of observable behavior as ___________ isto ____________A. Titchner; WatsonB. Aristotle; PlatoC. Watson; FreudD. Freud; Titchner
The attempt to understand the structure or characteristics of the mind was known as:Question 10Select one:a.Introspectionb.Structuralismc.Functionalismd.Psychoanalysis
Text 1An animal is said to have a theory of mind when it is able to act according to the mental states of other individuals. Psychologists David Premack and Guy Woodruff studied whether chimpanzees have such a theory of mind. They showed videos of human actors struggling with various problems. The chimpanzees were able to select photographs that showed the best tool to solve each actor’s problem.Text 2Biologist Daniel J. Povinelli and psychologists Kurt E. Nelson and Sarah T. Boysen have argued that previous research into whether chimpanzees have a theory of mind have not adequately addressed alternative explanations for the chimpanzees’ behaviors. Specifically, it may be the case that chimpanzees are following learned behaviors in a known environment, rather than applying a theory of mind in a novel situation.Based on the texts, how would Povinelli, Nelson, and Boysen (Text 2) most likely respond to Premack and Woodruff (Text 1)?*A. They would argue that nonhuman primates other than chimpanzees, such as baboons and gorillas, may also have a theory of mind.B. They would argue that the chimpanzees would be able to solve the problems themselves without referencing the photographs by struggling with the situation themselves and eventually determining the correct solution.C. They would encourage Premack and Woodruff to show the same videos and photgraphs to other nonhuman primates and compare the other nonhuman primates' reactions to the chimpanzees' reactions.D. They would suggest that placing the chimpanzee subjects in novel environments, such as rooms distinct from the chimpanzees' regular enclosures, may help better ascertain whether chimpanzees have a theory of mind.
Which school of psychology attempted to identify the basic elements of the mind?A. StructuralismB. FunctionalismC. BehaviourismD. Psychoanalysis
Upgrade your grade with Knowee
Get personalized homework help. Review tough concepts in more detail, or go deeper into your topic by exploring other relevant questions.