It is the week before ANZAC day and Ann’s house is robbed. The thieves steal many items, including her Great-Grandfather’s World War I medals. Ann is distraught and puts an advertisement in the local newspaper and offers a reward of $1,000 for whoever finds and returns the precious medals. Donny is a cleaner at the local shopping centre. As he was emptying the bins, the medals fell out of the rubbish. Not knowing whom they belong to, he took them to his local RSL Club, who in turn contacted Ann. Ann was overjoyed at the return of the medals. Donny then reads the paper and sees Ann’s advertisement. Donny now wants to claim the reward of $1,000.00 she promised. Donny argues he performed the required act to accept the offer. Does Ann have to pay him the $1,000.00?
Question
It is the week before ANZAC day and Ann’s house is robbed. The thieves steal many items, including her Great-Grandfather’s World War I medals. Ann is distraught and puts an advertisement in the local newspaper and offers a reward of 1,000.00 she promised. Donny argues he performed the required act to accept the offer. Does Ann have to pay him the $1,000.00?
Solution
The answer to this question depends on the legal jurisdiction and the specific laws regarding rewards and contracts in that area. However, in many jurisdictions, the answer would likely be no, Ann does not have to pay Donny the $1,000.00.
Here's why:
-
Unawareness of the Reward: Donny was not aware of the reward at the time he found the medals. In many jurisdictions, to form a contract (which a reward can be considered a form of), there needs to be mutual assent or a "meeting of the minds." This means both parties need to be aware of the terms. Donny did not know about the reward when he found the medals, so he could not have assented to the terms.
-
No Intention to Claim the Reward: Donny did not find the medals as a result of the reward offer. He found them while doing his job and turned them in without knowledge of a reward. His actions were not motivated by the reward, so it could be argued that he did not perform the act required to accept the offer.
-
The Act of Returning: The act required to claim the reward was to find and return the medals. While Donny did find the medals, he did not return them to Ann. The RSL Club did. Therefore, he did not fully perform the act required to claim the reward.
However, this is a general interpretation and the actual outcome could vary depending on the specific laws and court decisions in the jurisdiction where this occurred.
Similar Questions
Apply knowledge of structure to correctly label the parts of the information report. Note that the report is not necessarily in order. Concluding CommentSequence of InformationGeneral Statement ANZAC Day gives people an opportunity to remember its veterans of all wars and reflect upon the terrible nature of armed conflict. ANZAC day is a day of remembrance that takes place on the 25th of April each year. It is a time when Australians and New Zealanders remember the soldiers who fought in war and lost their lives in battle. ANZAC Day commemoration ceremonies are usually held at war memorials or local RSL clubs. ANZAC Day marches are mostly held in big cities.
What does the appeal to donate silver at the post office suggest about the British home front's role in WWI?A It underscores the critical role of civilian participation in supporting the war effort through material and financial contributionsB It indicates a shortage of traditional funding sources for the warC It reflects a preference for non-monetary donations over financial contributionsD It suggests a lack of governmental planning for war resources
One day in August, Aunt Alexandra invites her missionary circle to tea. Scout, wearing a dress, helps Calpurnia bring in the tea, and Alexandra invites Scout to stay with the ladies. Scout listens to the missionary circle first discuss the plight of the poor Mrunas, a benighted African tribe being converted to Christianity, and then talk about how their own Black servants have behaved badly ever since Tom Robinson’s trial. Miss Maudie shuts up their prattle with icy remarks. Suddenly, Atticus appears and calls Alexandra to the kitchen. There he tells her, Scout, Calpurnia, and Miss Maudie that Tom Robinson attempted to escape and was shot seventeen times. He takes Calpurnia with him to tell the Robinson family of Tom’s death. Alexandra asks Miss Maudie how the town can allow Atticus to wreck himself in pursuit of justice. Maudie replies that the town trusts him to do right. They return with Scout to the missionary circle, managing to act as if nothing is wrong.
To raise funds for the local veterans club, a group of BYU-Idaho students sold flags and memorial wreaths. The first week they sold six flags and 13 memorial wreaths and donated $346.78. The second week they sold 11 flags and 14 memorial wreaths and donated $444.21. Because it is difficult to make two different items, they want to sell only one item during the last two weeks of the fundraiser. They decide to sell only the item for which they can donate the most money per item sold. Select the most appropriate conclusion below:Group of answer choicesEven though it is difficult they should try to sell equal numbers of memorial wreaths and flags because they can donate an average of $17.535 for each item sold.They should sell memorial wreaths because they can donate $15.59 for every memorial wreath sold.They should sell flags because they can donate $19.48 for every flag sold.They should sell memorial wreaths because they can donate $19.48 for every memorial wreath sold.They should sell flags because they can donate $15.59 for every flag sold
To raise funds for the local veterans club, a group of BYU-Idaho students sold flags and memorial wreaths. The first week they sold six flags and 13 memorial wreaths and donated $346.78. The second week they sold 11 flags and 14 memorial wreaths and donated $444.21. Because it is difficult to make two different items, they want to sell only one item during the last two weeks of the fundraiser. They decide to sell only the item for which they can donate the most money per item sold. Select the most appropriate conclusion below:Group of answer choicesEven though it is difficult they should try to sell equal numbers of memorial wreaths and flags because they can donate an average of $17.535 for each item sold.They should sell memorial wreaths because they can donate $15.59 for every memorial wreath sold.They should sell flags because they can donate $19.48 for every flag sold.They should sell memorial wreaths because they can donate $19.48 for every memorial wreath sold.They should sell flags because they can donate $15.59 for every flag sold.
Upgrade your grade with Knowee
Get personalized homework help. Review tough concepts in more detail, or go deeper into your topic by exploring other relevant questions.