Knowee
Questions
Features
Study Tools

DSM and ICD critics question whether (a) trauma/stressor-related disorders are distinct from anxiety disorders, (b) posttraumatic stressis a reaction or disorder, (c) adjustment disorder is a “wastebasket” diagnosis, and (d) prolonged grief should be a disorder.• PDM frames PTSD/complex PTSD as a relational problem in which therapists must avoid inflicting secondary trauma.• Trauma is assessed along HiTOP’s “Internalizing,” “Thought Disorder,” and “Externalizing” spectra dimensions.• As part of moving away from a medical model, PTMF prefers the term “adversity” to “trauma

Question

DSM and ICD critics question whether (a) trauma/stressor-related disorders are distinct from anxiety disorders, (b) posttraumatic stressis a reaction or disorder, (c) adjustment disorder is a “wastebasket” diagnosis, and (d) prolonged grief should be a disorder.• PDM frames PTSD/complex PTSD as a relational problem in which therapists must avoid inflicting secondary trauma.• Trauma is assessed along HiTOP’s “Internalizing,” “Thought Disorder,” and “Externalizing” spectra dimensions.• As part of moving away from a medical model, PTMF prefers the term “adversity” to “trauma

...expand
🧐 Not the exact question you are looking for?Go ask a question

Solution

(a) The distinction between trauma/stressor-related disorders and anxiety disorders is a topic of debate among critics of DSM and ICD. While both involve a response to stressful or traumatic events, they are categorized differently based on the specific symptoms and their duration.

(b) The classification of posttraumatic stress as a reaction or a disorder is also contentious. Some argue that it is a natural reaction to traumatic events, while others view it as a disorder when the symptoms persist and interfere with daily life.

(c) Adjustment disorder is sometimes referred to as a "wastebasket" diagnosis because it is often used when a person's symptoms don't meet the criteria for a more specific disorder. Critics question the validity of this diagnosis.

(d) The inclusion of prolonged grief as a disorder is another point of contention. Some believe that it pathologizes a natural response to loss, while others argue that it can become a disorder when it is prolonged and impairs functioning.

The Psychodynamic Diagnostic Manual (PDM) views PTSD and complex PTSD as relational problems, emphasizing the importance of therapists avoiding the infliction of secondary trauma.

The Hierarchical Taxonomy of Psychopathology (HiTOP) assesses trauma along three spectra dimensions: "Internalizing," "Thought Disorder," and "Externalizing."

The Power Threat Meaning Framework (PTMF) prefers the term "adversity" to "trauma" as part of its move away from a medical model, suggesting that the term "trauma" may medicalize experiences that are part of the human condition.

This problem has been solved

Similar Questions

How is PTG related to coping in the context of trauma, according to Tedeschi and Calhoun (2004)?

define Trauma and stressor related disorder

Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and generalized anxiety disorder (GAD) both involve an exaggerated response to everyday stressors and a heightened state of anxiety or arousal that can impede concentration and daily functioning.  Both can be effectively treated with medication, including anxiolytics and antidepressants, and with therapy, the most effective of which is cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT).  Psychologists believe that the unpredictable nature of stressors plays a key role in the development and persistence of both disorders.  However, the response to predictable threats is believed to be normal.A study was conducted to investigate how individuals diagnosed with PTSD or GAD respond to predictable and unpredictable threats.  Twenty patients with PTSD, 20 patients with GAD, and 50 control participants took part in the study.  The groups did not differ significantly with respect to age or gender.  The study involved two conditions, each three minutes in duration.  During the first (predictable) condition, participants were shown a cue (red box) at random times while gazing through a viewing apparatus.  The cue signaled the imminent presentation of various loud noises such as thunder or screaming, meant to induce fear.  During the second (unpredictable) condition, the loud noise was presented randomly with no warning.The magnitude of the participants' startle response was measured by an eye blink reflex recorded with electrodes placed under the eyes (measured in microvolts [Table 1]).Table 1  Mean Startle Response in Microvolts by Group and ConditionPredictable UnpredictableControl 14 19PTSD 15 43GAD 18 37After the study, participants were asked to rate their subjective fear on a scale of 0 (no fear) to 10 (most fear).  The controls reported the least fear under both conditions.  PTSD participants expressed greater fear than GAD participants during the unpredictable condition, but GAD participants reported greater fear than PTSD participants during the predictable condition.C. Grillon, D. S. Pine, S. Lissek, S. Rabin, and M. Vythilingam ©2009 by Society of Biological Psychiatry. Question 16What is the main difference between GAD and PTSD?A.People with PTSD tend to hallucinate, whereas people with GAD do not.B.PTSD requires a long and consistent history of adjustment problems; GAD does not.C.PTSD requires a precipitating event to bring about the disorder; GAD does not.D.People with PTSD worry about a wide range of events; people with GAD worry about specific events.

Which of the following provides the most accurate information about posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) in response to sexual assault?Group of answer choicesA rape victim may experience PTSD, including feeling extremely anxious or even emotionally numb following the assault.Unfortunately, PTSD is an extremely persistent disorder, and more than half of all rape victims will still have PTSD more than a year after the assault.PTSD wipes away a woman’s memory of the rape, and she will not be able to recall the event until about a year after the assault.Unfortunately, PTSD cannot be treated with traditional psychotherapies; however, techniques that require hypnosis appear to be effective.

When people with post-traumatic stress disorder are asked to retrieve trauma-specific memories, significant activity can be seen in the Group of answer choicesa. amygdalab. hippocampusc. diencephalond. prefrontal cortex

1/3

Upgrade your grade with Knowee

Get personalized homework help. Review tough concepts in more detail, or go deeper into your topic by exploring other relevant questions.