A proper, scientific study of the effects of sentencing on criminal behavior requires an unbiased comparison of criminals with light sentences to criminals with harsher sentences. What real-world arrangement makes this kind of comparison possible?
Question
A proper, scientific study of the effects of sentencing on criminal behavior requires an unbiased comparison of criminals with light sentences to criminals with harsher sentences. What real-world arrangement makes this kind of comparison possible?
Solution 1
Un arreglo del mundo real que hace posible este tipo de comparación es el sistema judicial. En muchos países, los jueces tienen discreción para determinar la duración y la severidad de las sentencias dentro de ciertos límites establecidos por la ley. Esto significa que dos criminales que han cometido delitos similares pueden recibir sentencias muy diferentes. Al comparar el comportamiento posterior de estos criminales, los investigadores pueden obtener información sobre los efectos de las sentencias más leves en comparación con las sentencias más severas. Sin embargo, es importante tener en cuenta que este tipo de estudio puede ser complicado por una serie de factores de confusión, como las diferencias en el apoyo social y los servicios de rehabilitación disponibles para diferentes criminales.
Solution 2
A real-world arrangement that makes this kind of comparison possible is the existence of different jurisdictions with different sentencing guidelines. This allows for a natural experiment where researchers can compare the effects of sentencing on criminal behavior across different jurisdictions.
Here are the steps to conduct such a study:
-
Identify Jurisdictions: The first step is to identify different jurisdictions that have different sentencing guidelines for the same crimes.
-
Collect Data: The next step is to collect data on criminals, their crimes, their sentences, and their subsequent behavior after serving their sentences. This data can be collected from court records, prison records, and other relevant sources.
-
Match Criminals: Once the data is collected, the next step is to match criminals from different jurisdictions who committed the same crime but received different sentences. This matching should also take into account other relevant factors such as the criminal's age, prior criminal history, etc.
-
Compare Behavior: After matching, the next step is to compare the subsequent behavior of these criminals. This can be done by looking at recidivism rates, severity of re-offenses, etc.
-
Analyze Results: The final step is to analyze the results to see if there is a significant difference in the behavior of criminals who received light sentences compared to those who received harsher sentences.
This kind of study would provide valuable insights into the effects of sentencing on criminal behavior. However, it's important to note that this kind of study can be complex and challenging due to the many factors that can influence criminal behavior.
Similar Questions
If a judge wants to impose a significantly greater sentence on an accused than what the Criminal Code allows he/she can do so if there is a valid reason for his/her decision. Group of answer choices True False
Many studies have shown that, on release, offenders may be more likely to commit crimes than before they were imprisoned. In that case, ______________ may increase likelihood of crime, rather than diminish it.Group of answer choicesRetributionDeterenceIncapacitationGeneral Deterence
________________ such as probation and parole are often considered a less severe, alternative to imprisonment.Group of answer choicesrestorative justicecommunity correctionsintensive monitoringproblem oriented deterence
Of the four basic philosophical reasons for sentencing, _________________ is based on the belief that a wrongdoer who has freely chosen to violate society’s rules must be punished for the infractionGroup of answer choicesrehabilitationincapacitationretributiondeterence
What is the purpose of good-time credit in the context of prison sentences?AEncouraging inmates to break the rulesBPunishing inmates for bad behaviorCRewarding inmates for good behaviorDExtending inmates' sentencesWhat does a pardon typically involve in the legal system?AIncreasing the severity of punishmentBForgiveness of a convictionCAdding conditions to a sentenceDDelaying the legal processWhat is the main role of federal courts compared to other courts?APerforming judicial reviewsBBeing non-hierarchicalCHaving temporary judgesDFocusing on state laws
Upgrade your grade with Knowee
Get personalized homework help. Review tough concepts in more detail, or go deeper into your topic by exploring other relevant questions.