Context: Comparison of Proposed Strategies. • Two strategies have been proposed to alleviate the pressures caused by South East Queensland’s rapid Urbanisation. Option 1 Build a 3000-home development in Caboolture West with the aim of it, eventually becoming a satellite city. Option 2 Approve high density housing for all of Chermside West (15 to 25 storey buildings). • Evaluate the options using environmental, economic and social criteria. Consider the environmental, economic and social benefits (+) and weaknesses (-). Consider both long term and short-term effects for the two options, BY MAKING A DECISION MAKING MATRIX.
Question
Context: Comparison of Proposed Strategies. • Two strategies have been proposed to alleviate the pressures caused by South East Queensland’s rapid Urbanisation. Option 1 Build a 3000-home development in Caboolture West with the aim of it, eventually becoming a satellite city. Option 2 Approve high density housing for all of Chermside West (15 to 25 storey buildings). • Evaluate the options using environmental, economic and social criteria. Consider the environmental, economic and social benefits (+) and weaknesses (-). Consider both long term and short-term effects for the two options, BY MAKING A DECISION MAKING MATRIX.
Solution
Sure, here's a decision-making matrix evaluating the two options based on environmental, economic, and social criteria:
| Criteria/Options | Option 1: 3000-home development in Caboolture West | Option 2: High density housing in Chermside West |
|---|---|---|
| Environmental | ||
| Short-term (+) | Minimal disruption to existing ecosystems | Efficient use of land |
| Short-term (-) | Increased construction pollution | High construction pollution |
| Long-term (+) | Potential for green spaces and sustainable design | Reduced urban sprawl |
| Long-term (-) | Potential for increased car dependency | Potential strain on existing green spaces |
| Economic | ||
| Short-term (+) | Job creation in construction | Job creation in construction |
| Short-term (-) | High initial infrastructure costs | High initial infrastructure costs |
| Long-term (+) | Potential for economic growth in new city | Increased property values |
| Long-term (-) | Risk of insufficient economic activity | Potential for housing market saturation |
| Social | ||
| Short-term (+) | New housing opportunities | New housing opportunities |
| Short-term (-) | Potential disruption to existing communities | Potential disruption to existing communities |
| Long-term (+) | Creation of new community | Diversification of housing options |
| Long-term (-) | Risk of social isolation in satellite city | Potential for overcrowding |
This matrix provides a structured way to compare the two options based on different criteria and their short-term and long-term effects. The final decision should take into account the weight of each criterion based on the specific context and priorities of South East Queensland.
Similar Questions
• Chose a sustainable living feature or idea to minimise a social, economic or environmental consequence of urbanisation. • Research this idea including the possible implementation already in place in a Megacity. • Explain how this will create a more sustainable future for South East Queensland.
Explain why option 2 is better than option 1 Option 1: Build a 3000-home development in Caboolture West with the aim of it, eventually becoming a satellite city. Option 2: Approve high density housing for all of Chermside West (15 to 25 storey buildings).
Suggest how developments such as this can help urban areas to become moresustainable
Highlight four characteristics of sustainable urban form and structure
2. Justify to the Minister why your 1st option is the best and why your 9th option is the worst by providing a short-written report, Ignite Talk, OR diorama. You MUST answer the following questions:a) What is your first option and why, using research do you think it would lead to a sustainable future? (Planning Document 1)b) How would your first option both help and hinder the people of Australia? What POSITIVE and NEGATIVE effects would it have on people socially, economically, politically, culturally? (Planning Document 2)c) What evidence is there of your 1st option being successful in another country? (Planning Document 3)d) What are the positive and negative effects of option 1 on PHYSICAL and HUMAN geography? (Planning Document 2)
Upgrade your grade with Knowee
Get personalized homework help. Review tough concepts in more detail, or go deeper into your topic by exploring other relevant questions.